You Need to Know. And You Need to Say It.

This case concerns the leader of a small consulting firm operating on a project basis. He originally worked in sales and consulting, but following a reorganization he also took on an operational leadership role. The client projects he sold were delivered by project teams, which he also led.

With the change in role, the nature of the job changed. It was no longer enough to find professionally sound solutions and sell them. He also had to take responsibility for the functioning of the project teams, collaboration with clients and leadership communication.

THE STARTING POINT: THE QUESTION WAS NOT WHAT HE KNEW, BUT HOW HE OPERATED

Based on an earlier assessment using the Hogan personality assessment tool, it was clear that the leader was more task-oriented than people-oriented, with a direct and independent style. Under stress, he found it more difficult to maintain focus and was more likely to overlook other people’s requests.

Active listening therefore became the central competency in the coaching process. By his own assessment, he started at level 4 on a ten-point scale and set himself the goal of reaching level 7.

The difference was not merely theoretical. By his own account, under stress he was currently able to concentrate properly on the other person in approximately 20–30% of situations; his target was 60–70%. He also recognized that he tended to talk too much because talking helped him think through the options and search for a solution.

WHAT DOES ACTIVE LISTENING REALLY MEAN?

At the beginning of the process, it became clear that active listening primarily meant, for him, paying attention to the other person’s questions and answers and giving the other person an opportunity to speak. Through the work together, this understanding gradually changed and became more nuanced.

First, it became important to actually answer the other person’s question. This was followed by the recognition that the focus of the conversation should not be his own train of thought, but the other person’s problem. Finally, it also became clear that attention needs to be paid not only to the words being spoken, but to the emotional dimension as well.

THE DEVELOPMENT HAPPENED IN EVERYDAY WORK

The change was not achieved through general advice. Instead, we introduced concrete steps that could be built into everyday work.

The leader built time slots into his schedule when he gave project team members dedicated time to discuss the status of their work and any questions that had arisen. This deliberately meant putting his phone aside and being genuinely available.

Preparing for sales meetings also became a separate task. The purpose was to ensure that during the client meeting, time was not taken up by thinking and brainstorming, but could instead be devoted to the client and the client’s problem.

THE FIRST IMPORTANT REALIZATION: TALKING A LOT WAS NOT THE PROBLEM IN ITSELF

One of the interesting realizations during the process was that talking a lot was not the root of the problem in itself. It gave the leader time to think through the options and arrive at a solution.

The problem was that, in the meantime, the client or the other person had very little opportunity to speak. By the time the solution emerged, a significant part of the available conversation time had already passed. The change therefore was not simply about talking less, but about shifting the focus from thinking and searching for solutions to understanding the other person first.

WHEN THE PROBLEM ALSO HAS TO BE SAID OUT LOUD

The development process did not produce an immediately positive result in every situation. There was a case in which the leader felt that both he and a member of the project team understood the problem, so he tried to guide the other person toward how they should change through leading questions.

The situation did not improve. In retrospect, this became one of the most important lessons: it was not enough for both people to sense what the problem was. It had to be said out loud. Without direct communication, two people can easily talk about the same thing and still mean something different.

Naming the root of the problem ultimately prevented the project team member from leaving the company. Several months later, the person had become one of the company’s strongest-performing employees.

RECOGNIZING EMOTIONS ALSO PRODUCED A BUSINESS RESULT

The next step was recognizing that the leader needed to pay attention not only to the content of a conversation, but also to emotional signals. Because he did not find it easy to read subtle cues, he deliberately began asking direct questions to uncover what emotions were influencing the other person’s decision in a given situation.

This produced a direct business result in a specific client negotiation. The team secured an additional eighteen-month engagement with a client where it had previously become questionable whether the existing work could even be completed.

The person influencing the decision had serious concerns about the proposed solution: they were afraid that they would be held responsible if it failed. The leader had already learned about this fear from conversations with the person’s superiors, but had not thought it would be worth sharing this with the person directly.

Once he brought these feelings to the surface through direct questions, it became possible to address the real obstacle. The negotiation was therefore no longer only about professional issues, but also about what was actually behind the decision.

THE RESULT WAS NOT A “7”

The original goal was for the leader, by his own assessment, to move from level 4 to level 7 in active listening. At the end of the process, however, that was no longer the most important question.

The real result was that the leader knew what he needed to do to make the other person feel comfortable and safe in his presence – and, through genuine attention, he was able to put this into practice.

This not only improved his leadership effectiveness. Based on the results observed, the effectiveness of both the leader and his team increased significantly.

WHAT DOES THIS CASE SHOW?

One of the key lessons of the story is that leadership development does not necessarily mean acquiring more professional knowledge. Often, the greatest improvement comes from recognizing and changing a pattern of behavior that was previously connected to a leader’s strengths but has become limiting in a new leadership role.

The process included the Hogan personality assessment, the DIADAL coaching model, the 5E model and scaling, but none of these methods was the point in itself. The methods served to understand the specific leadership situation and translate the change into everyday practice.

We did not simply provide a method. We worked on how a leader operates – through specific situations, specific behaviors and specific business consequences.

RELATED SERVICE

Business and Executive Mentoring

VSMC Consulting tailors mentoring and coaching tools to the specific business and leadership situation of owners and executives. The goal is not development for its own sake, but to help the leader understand their own way of operating better and use that understanding effectively in everyday leadership situations.